Windows Vista Annoyances & Wishlist
I’ve been using Windows Vista (Ultimate x64) since February 2007 and so far I have had a mixed experience with it. First, I will start with what I do like: the Avalon effects look and feel very nice, the new start menu is nicer (especially the search box), the integrated search (esp. the Outlook 07 search), per-application volume mixer, and I’m sure a couple of other things I can’t remember at the moment. For all of the things I like about it, there seem to be a number of unnecessary, undesired aspects that should be fixed. These are not listed in any particular order.
1) Poor Driver Support
Since I’m using x64, I made sure to check that I would have driver support before I installed Vista. I got lucky and in fact most of my current devices were supported so I moved forward. Those drivers, however, were not totally working. My Creative X-Fi card has never completely worked. I get popping and clicking at random times and sometimes hard crashes while playing games. I’ve probably had more blue screens in the past year than I had the previous 2 years with Windows XP. I thought a major selling point of Vista was that more functions were moved to userspace so that wouldn’t happen.
2) Application Crashes and Errors
When I’m not getting a blue screen, I instead get a cryptic message about how the application “Stopped Working”. Sometimes the application continues to run fine and I just need to move the error dialog out of the way to continue my work. And the error dialogs have gotten more annoying than ever; first I get a dialog box, then after I close that I get a tooltip on the taskbar, finally I get a useless Windows Help dialog which allows me to search for an answer online (which of course never finds anything). This has, however, been less frequent with SP1.
3) Weird Design Choices
I won’t talk about UAC here; that gets its own section. Microsoft, what is wrong with Network Connections? Why did you decide to hide this very useful folder behind a useless one? You could have at least made it an item when I right-click on the network connection icon in the system tray. I’ve gone as far to make a shortcut to the network connections folder on my desktop just so I can skip the useless Network and Sharing Center. Also, why do you automatically try to guess what the contents of my folder and change my view? I just want the details view. I always want the details view. Don’t remove my columns or replace them with ones I don’t care about. Even applying the settings to all folders (under ‘Folder and Search Options’) doesn’t seem to fix this. Also, why does it ask me only if I want to reboot after applying updates? Sometimes I want to shutdown. You should always provide that option as well. And then there’s file sharing. Why did you make it so hard to share a single folder? At least offer Windows XP simple file sharing in read-only mode.
4) UAC?!
UAC has some major issues which need to be fixed right away. Microsoft should have just flat out copied Apple’s implementation on this. UAC pops up a vague dialog too often and ends up just being annoying. If people train themselves to just hit ‘Continue’ and ‘Allow’ all the time because you constantly bombard them with dialogs, then you end up with a security mechanism that is no better than none at all. First, start by making this dialog come up faster. For some reason, there seems to be a pause of up to a second (makes a difference - trust me) before the dialog shows up. Second, display some information about what it wants to do on there. Finally, I don’t see why there needs to be more than 1 dialog at a time. I don’t need a dialog to let me know that another is on its way.
From SP1 comes forth a new annoying dialog: “Do you want to move or copy files from this zone?”. It comes up when copying/moving files off of a Windows network share to your local computer. It seems to be related to Internet Explorer but I can’t get rid of it using the techniques I found doing a search.
5) Windows Update Takes Forever
Something definitely happened here. Windows Update has always been slow but now it takes forever. I have Vista installed on two pretty modern systems and sometimes it can take 30+ minutes just to install a couple of updates. Then it needs to ‘configure updates’ before restarting and after restarting. I’m not quite sure what its doing, due to cryptic messages, but please speed this up. Also, get rid of the nag screen about having to reboot my computer. At least offer an option to dismiss the dialog permanently. Finally, never, under any conditions, automatically restart my computer!
6) DirectX 10
I know the excuses about this being Vista only, but no one will really develop for it until Vista has a large enough user base. And with XP getting about 10% better framerates, don’t expect that to happen soon. If you really cared about DX10 and the future of computer gaming, you would have released DX10 for XP.
7) Sidebar Widgets Need Some Work
This is a small request which should be rather easy to fix. The problem is you didn’t spend enough time developing the main sidebar widgets. I should be able to click on the weather widget and it should popup the entire 7-day forecast, the stock widget should allow me to expand it vertically so I can view as many stocks at one time as I want, and there should be full-featured Outlook widgets and more MS developed widgets in general.
8 ) Save My Icon Positions!
This one is technically valid in Windows XP as well. We’ve all installed a new video driver before and know what happens - the installation resets the resolution to the Windows default and all of your icons get messed up. Instead, Microsoft should figure out how to save the icon positions automatically so they return to place after the video driver installation is finished.
9) Search Indexing Runs at Random Times
At random intervals, search indexing will decide to kick in. There needs to be an easy or, even better, automatic way to pause search indexing. For instance, search indexing should not run at all while playing games or while CPU usage is high. This is just a bad user experience. Give us a way to pause search indexing.
10) No Powertoys
This one is pretty straightforward - just bring PowerToys to Vista. PowerToys has become such a critical part of the XP user’s experience, Vista should have actually shipped with it.
11) Networking Issues
Sometimes Vista will decide to connect to both wired and wireless internets at the same time and randomly send data over the one it likes best. The standard rule should be to disable wireless if the wired connection is operating. This is very annoying at work where wired connections are behind the firewall, whereas wireless connections are not. Occasionally, I wonder why I can’t connect to the intranet and then figure out it’s connected to wireless again.
For the reasons above, I’ve been unable to recommend Vista to my friends and family. Microsoft, please help!